Bart Shooting
January 9th, 2009The shooting of a man by a Bart police officer is on the front page of the Chronicle, and it catches my eight-year-old daughter’s attention as we pass by the news rack on the way to her school. She has lots of questions: What happened? Why did the officer shoot the man? What was the man doing?
I answer that no one knows all the facts, and then tell her some of the facts I do know. One man was shot. One officer did the shooting. One bullet was fired. One life ended. The dead man was unarmed. There were many people around yelling.
I imagine the situation was very tense, I tell her. It would have been terrible to be there. It’s a tragedy for everyone involved: the dead man, his family and friends, the officer–even him.
I don’t tell her everything I know. I leave out that the man was lying face down on the ground when the officer shot him. I don’t want that picture in her head. I don’t want her to be afraid of the police.
In the evening, it’s still on her mind. She wants to talk about it as she’s getting ready for bed and makes me follow her to the bathroom and talk to her from the hall while she pees. The questions, the same questions again and again, stop briefly. I hear her urine splashing into the toilet, the toilet paper roll spinning, water running while she washes her hands.
Her obsession I think is healthy and normal. I’m glad she wants to talk to my wife and me about it, because she’s talking about it to her friends. Amaya says he was shot 26 times, she says. I quickly correct that; one bullet, one shot, I say. Don’t believe everything your friends tell you. People make things up, fill in the blanks when they don’t know the details. I realize that’s what I’m doing when I speak to her about the incident; I don’t know everything. I wasn’t there, and even if I was, I still wouldn’t, couldn’t know everything.
Since it’s occupying her mind, since it’s got her focus, I try to use the incident as a teachable moment. I try to put some ideas into her head. The police aren’t perfect, but they are better than the alternative: no police. Give them the benefit of the doubt, and let them do their job. When an officer tells you to do something, do it. A gun can kill even if you don’t mean it to. At 2AM, when people are rowdy, bad things can happen.
There’s a video of the shooting, several videos actually, on the Internet. My daughter knows about them, and she wants to know if I’ve watched them. I say, “No.” It’s not a lie. I haven’t watched the videos, and I don’t want to. I don’t want those images in my daughter’s head or my own. The videos exist; the people who need to see them have seen them. I’m not one of those people.
Tragic, terrible, violent things happen; lives end in an instant. I knew that before the Bart shooting. Gradually, sooner than I’d like, my daughter is learning it too.